In this first episode of our Spring 2026 “Going Deeper” series, Pastor Josh expands on Sunday’s sermon from 1 Timothy 1:8–11 and focuses specifically on Paul’s inclusion of homosexuality in the list of lawless behaviors (1 Timothy 1:10).

This conversation approaches the topic intentionally, biblically, and compassionately—addressing both the most common cultural arguments in favor of same-sex relationships and the most common Scriptural arguments used to reinterpret or discredit the Bible’s teaching.

The goal is not to win debates, but to think biblically, respond lovingly, and remain anchored to truth.

I. Argument from logic and nature

1. Same sex relationships provide an actual good.

A. 1 Corinthians 10:31.

B. Answer: Man’s highest good is to glorify God.

2. Same sex relationships do no harm.

A. Links:

• https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/adult-health/in-depth/health-issues-for-gay-men/art-20047107

• https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/health/wellness-and-prevention/gay-and-bisexual-mens-health-issues

B. Philippians 2:4

C. 1 Corinthians 6:18

D. Answer: Everything you do has an effect on others and not all effects are immediately evident.

3. Same sex attracted people were born that way.

A. Psalm 51:5

B. Romans 3:23

C. Romans 5:12

D. Answer: All people are born into sin and all sinful actions are held in account.

4. Same sex attraction exists in the animal kingdom.

A. Romans 8:22

B. Genesis 1:27–28

C. Answer: God made us superior to the animals.

5. Procreation is not a basis for morality.

A. Answer: The possibility of procreation is inextricable from God’s design for sex.

II. Argument from Scripture

1. Biblical prohibition is about abusive relationships.

A. 1 Cor. 6:9; 1 Tim. 1:9–10

B. Answer: An honest reading of Scripture prohibits all same-sex, sexual relationships.

2. God continues to reveal himself in new ways.

A. Ephesians 2:20

B. Answer: God has not given new revelation since the first century.

3. Jesus did not speak on/condemn same sex relationships.

A. Matthew 19:4–6

B. Answer: Jesus spoke in concert with Old and New Testament authors, recognizing proper martial relations as only between one man and one woman.

4. LGBTQ-affirming communities are fuller of love and acceptance than non-affirming communities.

A. Matthew 22:39

B. Answer: Christians are commanded by Christ to show the truth in love to everyone.

Handout Link